How Much Is Good Condo Management Worth? 360,000 Listings Say ★5-Rated Buildings Sell 2.7% Higher, Rising to 6% After Two Years
Using about 360,000 resale condo listings in Greater Tokyo, Yokohama City University found that buildings holding the top ★5 management rating list about 2.7% higher than unrated ones, and the gap widens to 6.0% one and a half to two years after the rating is published. For buildings over 40 years old, even ★3 carries a premium. We explain the findings, how to look up a rating, how many Osaka buildings are registered, and how to use it when viewing.
In one sentence
When you view a resale condo in Japan, the agent often says "this building is well managed." What that is worth has never been clear. A study published on 13 November puts a number on it for the first time: across about 360,000 resale condo listings in Greater Tokyo, buildings holding the top ★5 management rating list about 2.7% higher than buildings with no rating, and the gap widens to 6.0% one and a half to two years after the rating is published [1]. The data are from Tokyo, but the rating scheme is nationwide and 1,296 buildings in Osaka Prefecture are already registered [2]. For anyone shopping for a resale condo in Osaka, this is a tool you can use right away.
What the study found
The research was led by Associate Professor Masatomo Suzuki of Yokohama City University's Graduate School of Data Science. At Home supplied listing data for about 360,000 resale condos in Tokyo, Kanagawa, Chiba and Saitama, the Condominium Management Companies Association supplied the rating data, and the two were merged for statistical analysis [1]. There are four main conclusions [1]:
- An overall premium of about 2.7%. Buildings rated ★5 (90 to 100 points) list about 2.7% higher than buildings with no rating.[1]
- The gap grows over time. Less than half a year after publication the premium is 2.4%; at one to one and a half years it is 2.9%; at one and a half to two years it reaches 6.0%. The researchers' explanation is that the market needs time to absorb the information.[1]
- Rated buildings were already slightly higher before the rating. On average they traded 0.6% higher before the rating was published. Good management was already being sensed at viewings; the rating turned that feeling into a visible price.[1]
- Older buildings benefit more. For buildings under 20 years old, a premium appears only with ★5. For buildings over 40 years old, even ★3 brings a premium simply by having a rating at all.[1]
The release also stresses that these figures are averages from a statistical model and neither describe nor guarantee the price of any individual unit [1].
The background is that Japan's condo stock is ageing. There are about 7.24 million condominium units nationwide (end of 2025), of which about 1.59 million are over 40 years old, a figure expected to rise to about 3.13 million in ten years and 5.04 million in twenty. Meanwhile, only 323 rebuilding projects had been completed in total as of the end of March 2025 [1]. Most old buildings will never be rebuilt. Their only route to a long life is good management, so whether management quality shows up in prices directly affects whether owners bother.
What the stars are, and how many Osaka buildings have them
The Condominium Management Appropriateness Evaluation System is a private scheme run by the Condominium Management Companies Association. Evaluators holding a management business manager or condominium manager licence score each building in five areas: management structure, building and equipment, owners' association finances, seismic diagnosis and living-related matters. The 100-point score is divided into six grades from ★5 (90 to 100 points) down to ★0 and published online, where anyone can search by building name or area [3]. It is separate from the government's Management Plan Certification, which is a national scheme certified by municipalities such as Osaka City. Many buildings obtain both through a one-stop application [2].
As of the end of September 2026, 13,449 buildings were registered nationwide, up 1,181 from the end of June [2]. By grade: 4,977 buildings are ★5 (37%), 5,799 are ★4 (43%), 2,285 are ★3 (17%), 384 are ★2, only 4 are ★1 and none are ★0 [2]. In other words, buildings that choose to register are already a well-managed group, with eight in ten at ★4 or above. Unregistered buildings are the majority, and their management quality is invisible to outsiders.
By prefecture, Tokyo leads with 4,230 buildings, followed by Kanagawa with 1,765 and Osaka Prefecture with 1,296, third in the country; Hyogo has 785 and Kyoto 378 [2]. Set against the number of resale condos sold in Osaka City each year, 1,296 registered buildings cover only a small slice of the market. In Osaka, simply having a rating is still scarce information.
Why large and newer buildings earn ★5 more easily
The same registration report contains figures that help calibrate expectations [2]:
- Size. Among buildings with 400 or more units, 78.0% are ★5; among those with fewer than 50 units, only 30.5%. Large buildings have on-site management staff and bigger reserve funds, which makes the criteria easier to meet.[2]
- Age. Among buildings completed in 2021 or later, 63.6% are ★5. Buildings completed before 1980 (roughly 40 to 50 years old) also include ★5 ratings, at 7.1% of registered buildings of that vintage.[2]
- Is the repair reserve actually being collected? Among buildings on a "step-up" reserve plan, where contributions rise in stages over the years, 90.1% of ★5 buildings are collecting as planned, against only 45.2% of ★3 buildings.[2]
The last point matters most. Step-up plans are common in Japan. The plan looks fine on paper, but when the year for an increase arrives, owners' meetings frequently vote it down and the money is not collected. To a large degree, the star grade reflects whether this has actually been done.
What it means for buyers in Osaka
First, check whether the building has a rating before you view it. Search by building name on the evaluation website [3]. If it has ★4 or ★5, a professional has already looked at the things you cannot easily verify yourself: management structure, the long-term repair plan and the reserve fund's finances. If it is not listed, that does not mean management is poor, but it does mean you will have to ask more questions yourself.
Second, for old buildings, even ★3 is a plus. The study found a premium for ★3 in buildings over 40 years old [1]. A sizeable share of resale condos sold in Osaka City are over 40 years old, and what buyers in that segment fear most is a future major repair with no money and a sudden jump in contributions. A rated old building has at least put that information on the table.
Third, do not read 2.7% as "buy and gain 2.7%." It is an average difference in listing prices and is already built into what you pay [1]. Think of it as a signal: the slightly higher asking price buys certainty about management. Conversely, if a ★5 building is priced the same as unrated neighbours, it deserves a second look.
Fourth, well-managed buildings also get better terms for common-area funds. The Japan Housing Finance Agency's "Mansion Sumai-ru Bond" for owners' associations carries a standard rate of 2.000% for the 2026 issue, while buildings with a high rating from an industry body receive 2.050% [4]. The difference is small, but it shows financial institutions starting to differentiate by management quality.
Fifth, after buying, you can push your own building to apply. Ratings are applied for by the management company or the owners' association. If your building is unrated but actually well run, proposing an application at the owners' meeting is a low-cost way to raise the transparency and liquidity of the whole building.
Summary
This study turns "well managed" from a verbal promise into a number you can look up and compare: ★5 buildings list 2.7% higher on average, the gap grows with time, and the effect is strongest for older buildings [1]. Osaka Prefecture has 1,296 registered buildings, skewed toward high grades, but unregistered buildings remain the majority [2]. When viewing resale condos in Osaka, we suggest making "check the rating, ask about the reserve fund, read the long-term repair plan" a fixed routine. If you would like to know whether a particular building is rated, or how to read the reserve-fund figures in the management disclosure report, please get in touch through our contact form.
Sources
- アットホーム株式会社(PR TIMES), ―アットホームとマンション管理業協会が支援する横浜市立大学の研究成果― 管理状態の良いマンションは評価価格が約3%高い ~管理の質が中古マンション価格に与える影響を実証~, Nov 13, 2026 (accessed Nov 17, 2026)
- 一般社団法人マンション管理業協会, マンション管理適正評価制度 登録状況等について(2026年度 第2四半期終了時点), Oct 13, 2026 (accessed Nov 17, 2026)
- 一般社団法人マンション管理業協会, マンション管理適正評価サイト(制度の概要・評価ランク・検索), Nov 17, 2026 (accessed Nov 17, 2026)
- 住宅金融支援機構, 【マンションすまい・る債】(2026年度募集の利率), Nov 12, 2026 (accessed Nov 17, 2026)
This article is general information, not investment, tax or legal advice. Figures are as of the publication of the sources listed and may have changed since. Please consult a professional for decisions about your situation.

